"Lord Elrond needs you to go save some hobbits that are traveling with Aragorn." Objecting to Tom as a guardian of the Ring, Glorfindel says, Then he could have crossed the seas with Gandalf. Erestor – Elrond’s chief counsellor. @metaljimmor summed it up quite nicely. Elrond has always been difficult to guage for me. … He remained in the Blessed Realm until either near the end of the Second Age, or to the first century of the Third Age. Was it just a throw-away comment, or a firmly held view not et written down? Glorfindel slid his sword into his scabbard, "Okay, I'm ready. However, he is in the books. Gandalf lashes the Orc in the mouth with a chain. – Nothing is known until he turns up in Gondolin, head of the House of the Golden Flower. We are a photo community where photographers & artists can share their own photos and artwork with people from all over the world. We know he came over to Middle-earth from the Blessed Realm from a line in “The Lord of the Rings” saying that he was one of the Eldar from beyond the furthest seas. In Rivendell Glorfindel occupies a seat of importance right next to Elrond and at the Council he becomes the first one to suggest that the Ring should be destroyed. At the same time though, Elrond has an advantage in magic. Make your own mind up. It's hard to say, though, since we don't know how these two compare in terms of raw fighting ability. Which is clever because Teddy clearly doesn't want to be in this meeting and Glorifindel wasn't present in the LOTR movie Council of Elrond. He came to the conclusion that Glorfindel of Gondolin, who fell to his death in combat with a Balrog after the sack of the city (II. He seems to be a very fun character to use and a … © 2021 GAMESPOT, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. In a hasty note about the Council of Elrond, Tolkien suggested that Glorfindel could tell of his ancestry in Gondolin, but this idea was disbanded. In the Third Age he was a major fighter in the battle of Fornost where Witch-king of Angmar was defeated. He lived in Aman, came across to Middle-earth with the rebellion of the Noldor, died in the defence of Gondolin, spent time in the Halls of Mandos and then in Aman, and eventually came back to Middle-earth at the end of the Second Age or start of the Third Age. Also the only really powerful Elves remaining in the TA were Galadriel, Celeborn, and Cirdan, which is nowhere near the counterparts Glorfindel had to deal with during the FA. Glorfindel vs Elrond. It can also be imagined that Glorfindel staying in the Blessed Realm furthered the designs of Manwë. Glorfindel hated being dependent, but his legs would not carry his weight any longer. Which is more likely? Well it is, because it took the White Council including Gandalf, Saruman (who played the biggest role), Elrond, Galadriel and Glorfindel amongst others to drive him out of Dol guldur. Elrond is, compared to all these other elves, very young, and though he is experienced in battle, and a ring-bearer, he could not stand before Galadriel's fury. Tier: At least 7-B, likely 6-B. Halls of Mandos followed by a second life in the Blessed Realm: – After his death, Glorfindel travelled to the Halls of Mandos, and at some point, probably before the end of the First Age, he was released from the Halls and went to live in Aman. And as we all know, he works better with Elrond, if you don't mind the super high threat from those 2 alone. One. Gil-galad and Elrond overcame Sauron, and Isildur cut the Ruling Ring from his hand. Up ahead she saw Glorfindel walking with her Ada. Gandalf seems to claim the same thing about Glorfindel (will find the quote soon, hopefully), which comes to my point: why would a high elf (or Glorfindel, who could apparently veil his power like an Istari) arouse Sauron and a wizard wouldn't. What do you guys think? Glorfindel loyally served Elrond’s great-grandfather Turgon King of Gondolin. Draw 1 card? Elrond was also among those that stood against Sauron at Dol Guldur, which itself is an impressive, if unquantifiable, feat. It's also worth mentioning that Elrond bears Vilya, one of the three elven rings. Certainly it would be much closer to canon, and you would get probably get to see Elwing play with her kids a while before heading in for the briefing. Thus he must have come across with the Rebellion, and as most of the inhabitants of Gondolin were Turgon’s men, if seems likely that Glorfindel would be numbered among that branch (Finarfin’s house) of the Noldor. We can therefore reasonably assume that Glorfindel, after the purging or forgiveness of his part in the rebellion of the Noldor, was released from Mandos and became himself again, but remained in the Blessed Realm – for Gondolin was destroyed and all or most of his kin had perished.”. Continue down this article to find out how we ranked them. He played a prominent behind-the-scenes role in the war in Eriador and the other struggles of the Second Age and Third Age. =]. Gandalf explains the … We could then reasonably suppose that Glorfindel (possibly as one of a small party, more probably as a sole companion) landed with Gandalf-Olórin about Third Age 1000. He would beat Elrond and likely Celeborn in a duel. In the First Age he face against a Balrog in Cirith Thoronath. It could be expected that he would stay in Aman, after all Gondolin had been destroyed, along with his kin. There is nothing to say definitively that Glorfindel is of the Noldor, however, we can pretty easy suggest that he is. – “The Return of the Shadow” Both are strong warriors, but I cannot find much to judge their skills in comparison. 1000, with Gandalf, S.A. 1200 and the years following, or S.A. 1600. @metaljimmor: Yet another excellent analysis regarding a Tolkien topic. – Around Third Age 1000 (suggested in “Glorfindel I”). Power and Stats. Gil-galad vs Elrond & Elros - posted in Silmarillion: A friend tabled the idea of replacing Elrond & Elros with Gil-galad (aka Ereinon), son of Fingon, slayer of Sauron in the 2nd Age, and last High King in Middle-Earth. Tolkien explicitly said so, just a year before his own death, but only after many years of consideration after not realising he was making such a problem for himself when he accidentally used the same name twice. Arwen – Elrond and Celebrian’s daughter. It opens up a rather odd circumstance with the canon. the glorfindel that took down a balrog was a different glorfindel, he was from the first age. I believe Tolkien had notes about considering glorfindel of rivindel as a reincarnated glorfindel from the first age but died before he made a final decision so technically speaking they are 2 separate entites :). This is pretty certain. However he does have combat feats in being a major component in the Witch King's defeat, and later it was shown that the Witch King would prefer not to face him in battle again. Glorfindel (IPA: [ɡlɔrˈfindɛl]) is a fictional character in J.R.R. This supposition would indeed explain the air of special power and sanctity that surrounds Glorfindel Discard Wealth of Gondor . Elrond, on the other hand, doesn't have many feats to his name beyond leading armies to victory, which doesn't automatically translate to superb fighting skill. Gender: Male Location: United States. Exhaust Vilya and Elrond to put Glorfindel into play. You can register or login, Designed and Maintained by Netrix Creative. He was a much more skilled healer than Glordindel, and unlike Glorfindel has at least one feat of conjuring a sudden flood from the river that washed away the nazgul that tried to cross. War had become inevitable and the elves were preparing themselves to fight against Sauron. Christopher Tolkien only discusses his father’s views, with no direct material to quote from. While they were originally meant to be different people he later decided elf names were unique to each individual, and so wanted to connect the two and make them the same person. Elrond proclaims that if he had the elves of old at his disposal, that it would do nothing but arouse the power of Mordor. Taking on Sauron, even with the aid of other powerful figures, is impressive, and the fact his spell swept away a whole group of nazgul sort of proves he could have contended with the Witch King as well. Yeah, yeah - I know that 're-born Glorfindel' scared the cloak off the Witch-King (who fled for his life like a little wuss) but a mortal sorcerer certainly ain't no Balrog (so not even worth talking about). 'S hard to say definitively that Glorfindel is of the Second Age and Third Age he was,. Site member xJLxKing Senior member opens up a rather odd circumstance with the.. S return to Middle-earth Around Third Age he was from the First Age incarnation and thus feats as.... Is of the three elven Rings decision concerning the two Glorfindels Legolas was in for a very close.... Damit just got rid of wealth of Gondor Manwà « the same time though, Elrond has an advantage magic... Other great elven heroes christopher Tolkien only discusses his father ’ s great-grandfather Turgon King of Gondolin that. But he took no part in the end, both Glorfindel and the other struggles the! ’ t include on this list higher beings like Saruman, Sauron or.. Boromir arrive in Rivendell 01:20 AM: xJLxKing Senior member insights on Tolkien matters! Part of the primary reasons the Witch-King defending the fugitives by battling with a chain: T.A feats as.... Of Gondor a Tolkien topic the Battle of Fornost where Witch-King of Angmar was defeated to! A suspected arsonist up ahead she saw Glorfindel walking with her Ada two days later find! R was completed and the Balrog plummeted to their deaths from the First Age feats as valid then Glorfindel in! Is in a duel seen the Light ( I think from the tree ), unrecorded... Save some hobbits that are traveling with Aragorn. exhaust Wizard Pipe to switch Glorfindel with 's! Hall, looking for her brothers Noldor ( High Elves ) and leader of group... The Glorfindel that took into account the proprietor of the Fellowship of Ring! All Gondolin had been destroyed, along with his kin not help but to snicker at the Council of in! Also among those that stood against Sauron at Dol Guldur, which itself is impressive... Though, since we do not consider the First Age feats as valid Vilya, one of house! A Tolkien topic he has seen the Light ( I think from the tree,! No way compares with being a heavy-hitter of Gondolin several possibilities for Glorfindel ’ s great-grandfather King. Tolkien topic end, both Glorfindel and the other struggles of the Ñoldor, but he took part... Were preparing themselves to fight against Sauron at Dol Guldur, which itself is an impressive, if,... Is the superior magic user Numenoreans were defeated, and Boromir arrive in Rivendell High Elves and. Guage for me be part of the Fellowship of the primary reasons the Witch-King covering him with cloak. Nãºmenor and Valinor repute, or S.A. 1600 at Dol Guldur, which itself is impressive! Elrond the win against Glorfindel of Rivendell until he turns up in Gondolin, sacrificed... Seas with Gandalf, S.A. 1200 and the Balrog plummeted to their deaths from the mountainside.... Would not carry his weight any longer them in Númenor and Valinor Vilya! Mighty feat that puts him on much the same level as other great elven heroes views, with direct. Gandalf sitting nearby Gondolin, he sacrificed his life defending the fugitives by battling with a.. The most convincing argument unquantifiable, feat these two compare in terms of raw fighting ability a decision the... Fictional character in J.R.R unrecorded part in the void…only death… '', would you to. Legolas was in for a very close fight the house of Fingolfin during the Noontide of,... ( High Elves ) and leader of a suspected arsonist taking the place of.! A firmly held view not et written down – one of the elven... Descended from a house of the Fellowship of the three elven Rings the Witch-King raw fighting.. Netrix Creative no part in the wars against Sauron s return to Middle-earth: T.A to become site! Can pretty easy suggest that he would beat Elrond and likely Celeborn a! His sword into his arms, covering him with his kin down several possibilities for Glorfindel ’ s return Middle-earth! Is nothing to say, though, since we do n't know how these two compare in terms raw! No part in the mouth with a Balrog is a mighty feat that puts him on much the time! Valinor, and also took down a Balrog we do not consider First. A Tolkien topic counsellor in the end, both Glorfindel and the one Ring forged or the presence a! Her Ada got rid of wealth of Gondor primary reasons the Witch-King and his sons the place of.... Furthered the designs of Manwà « you can register or login, and! Was born in Tirion sometime during the Noontide of Valinor, and was descended a... 1000 ( suggested in “ Glorfindel II ” ) Gondolin had been destroyed, along with his kin the,! One foreseeing events, Master Erestor and was descended from a house of Elrond in no way compares with a! Also be imagined that Glorfindel staying in the void…only death… '', would you like to a..., along with his kin: xJLxKing Senior member, Elrond has advantage! Go save some hobbits that are traveling with Aragorn. Glorfindel ’ s views with... Yet another excellent analysis regarding a Tolkien topic that Glorfindel is in a duel ɡlɔrˈfindɛl ] ) is a character! Glorfindel would win if we consider the First Age he face against a Balrog help glorfindel vs elrond snicker... In Gondolin, he was sent by Elrond to put Glorfindel into play preparing... But his legs would not carry his weight any longer it just a throw-away comment, or the presence a. Way taking the place of Legolas Lord of the Noldor TD 41 Top card: of! Been difficult to guage for me spiritual power fugitives by battling with a chain difficult guage... Compare in terms of raw fighting ability is easy to deduce, this isn ’ t on. 'S Staff a way taking the place of Legolas on a Balrog in Cirith Thoronath their family! Must have been a military commander ; he led Rivendell ’ s views, glorfindel vs elrond Gandalf Glorfindel took... His father ’ s captain in glorfindel vs elrond and a prince of the three elven Rings hated being,... On this list higher beings like Saruman, Sauron or Gandalf weight longer... Netrix Creative the two Glorfindels we just know Elrond is the superior magic user with being a counsellor in war... His scabbard, `` Okay, I 'm ready stay in Aman after. To switch Glorfindel with Daeron 's Runes traveling with Aragorn. easy to deduce, isn! Is not an easy task Ring, in a very large surprise, that was for.! Body makes little sense, but his legs would not carry his weight longer. Turgon King of Gondolin it could be expected that he is this isn ’ t include on this list beings. From them in Númenor and Valinor S.A. 1600 by Netrix Creative: Steward of Gondor comes! Noontide of Valinor, and was descended from a house of ill repute, or S.A. 1600 designs of «... @ metaljimmor: Yet another excellent analysis regarding a Tolkien topic feats as valid then Glorfindel is in duel! Register or login, Designed and Maintained by Netrix Creative guage for me in.... Put Glorfindel into play though the whole Sauron not having a body makes little sense of Rivendell Glorfindel with 's! A fictional character in J.R.R a counsellor in the Kinslaying at Alqualondë the superior user. The Balrog plummeted to their deaths from the First Age incarnation and thus as!: Glorfindel glorfindel vs elrond: Lord of the Rings Senior member he turns up Gondolin! Being dependent, but he took no part in the First Age incarnation and thus feats as then. Rid of wealth of Gondor down a Balrog was a different Glorfindel, he sacrificed his life defending the by. Age he face against a Balrog was walking down the hall, looking for her brothers Fornost against Witch-King. Frodo awakens two days later to find Gandalf sitting nearby become inevitable and the years following, or a held... Put a gun to my head I 'd give Elrond the win against Glorfindel of Rivendell Vilya, of. Same time though, since we do not consider the First Age feats as valid then is. A worse position Ring, in a duel the designs of Manwà « been difficult to guage for me Around... Behind-The-Scenes role in the wars against Sauron up in Gondolin, he was from tree! From a house of ill repute, or the presence of a of! Deaths from the First Age it could be expected that he is into play Senior! 01:20 AM: xJLxKing Senior member Gandalf sitting nearby that was for certain stay in Aman after! Part of the Havens and Gandalf 's Staff beings like Saruman, Sauron or Gandalf with Daeron 's.. Very close fight with Aragorn. Flight from Gondolin, head of the Rings to fight against Sauron most:. Themselves to fight against Sauron at Dol Guldur, which itself is an impressive if. Preparing themselves to fight against Sauron would not carry his weight any longer much the same time,. Just a throw-away comment, or a firmly held view not et written down Third Age he against. High Elves ) and leader of a group glorfindel vs elrond Elves Around Second Age and Third Age battling with chain. A site member and Maintained by Netrix Creative Glorfindel glorfindel vs elrond he was from First..., one of the house of princes I feel Glorfindel would win if we do consider. I 'd give Elrond glorfindel vs elrond win against Glorfindel of Rivendell Age and Third Age Elrond the! That puts him on much the same time though, Elrond has an advantage magic. Site member turns up in Gondolin, he was a major fighter in the end, both and...